For more than 50 years, the RELs have collaborated with school districts, state departments of education, and other education stakeholders to help them generate and use evidence and improve student outcomes. Read more
Home Blogs Where the rubber meets the road: Exploring ideas of “use and usefulness” in a virtual school partnership
Virtual school is still the newest place on the map of how we educate children, although the pandemic brought it into the spotlight like never before. Since 2014, the REL Southeast has explored what it means to have a research-practice partnership with virtual schools through the work with Florida Virtual School (FLVS). This year, with the start of the 2022-2027 REL cycle, we are taking an even closer look at how this partnership might help us understand what it takes to use and adapt existing IES resources in virtual school settings.
In the 2022 National Academies Press book, The Future of Research at IES: Advancing an Equity-Oriented Science1, the authors (a committee charged with providing guidance for future research at NCER and NCES) described "use and usefulness" of educational research as a major lens "through which to identify salient questions, analyze key issues, and orient our recommendations." (p. 24). They noted that:
"As outlined in ESRA, the functions of IES include obligations to "promote the use, development, and application of knowledge gained from scientifically valid research activities," and "promote the use and application of research and development to improve practice in the classroom." Thus, the committee understands that IES's function is not merely to "disseminate," or inform the public about, research findings, but to take steps to enable their use in practice. As a result, the committee identified use and usefulness of research as a theme that must be consistently addressed." (p. 25)
They also proposed a new IES project type called "Knowledge Mobilization." Knowledge mobilization projects would2:
The concept of "Use and Usefulness of Education Research" combined with the vision of Knowledge Mobilization projects offers an especially fascinating approach for viewing the challenges that virtual schools face in implementing evidence-based practices, along with different ways in which research-practice partnerships can work. For some topics, there may be no existing IES resources, such as practice-guides or tools, that provide a short-cut to identifying and implementing practices with a strong evidence base. In the last REL cycle, for example, our FLVS partnership discussed the emerging research literature on how teachers can form strong connections with students when working in virtual settings, and we produced new resources that summarized available evidence and recommendations. (See, for example, our infographics on social presence research: When Teachers and Students are Separated: Strategies from Research on Social Presence for Teaching at a Distance and Beyond the Virtual Classroom: Extending the Social Presence Model to Extracurricular Activities in Online Schools.)
In this cycle, however, FLVS is interested in a deep exploration of evidence-based practices for elementary literacy. This is an area in which IES and the What Works Clearinghouse resources are particularly plentiful and strong. A great deal of work has gone into practice guides and other tools to make the research on literacy instruction easier for schools and teachers to use in their practice. However, these resources were developed within the context of brick-and-mortar schools, and this may make them more difficult to use at all levels in a virtual school. For example, the barriers and facilitators for implementing certain practices may be different in virtual settings than in traditional settings and require more extensive adaptation. The structure and systems of virtual schools may also differ in ways that affect knowledge flow and successful implementation of practices across the organization.
To our knowledge, no one has closely examined what might be needed to support the use and usefulness of existing IES resources on evidence-based elementary literacy practices in a virtual setting. How well do these resources translate to the virtual school context so that teachers, coaches, and leaders in those schools can use them? What supports or changes might be needed so that those who work in virtual schools will find them most useful? These are the questions we are currently exploring.
Our partnership work kicked off this summer, but we have already made plans for our initial forays into this new territory:
The IES infographic, Implementing Evidence-Based Literacy Practices, uses the metaphor of a roadmap as its framework. Continuing that metaphor, we believe that where the "rubber meets the road" in changing student outcomes will be in the everyday interactions between teachers, families, and students. With the wealth of existing resources developed by IES outlining evidence-based practices for brick-and-mortar schools, our challenge will be to identify ways these resources can best be used to help supercharge those teacher/family/student interactions in the context of virtual schools. Stay tuned!
1 National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. (2022). The Future of Education Research at IES: Advancing an Equity-Oriented Science. The National Academies Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/26428.
2 National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. (2022). The Future of Education Research at IES: Advancing an Equity-Oriented Science (p. 93). The National Academies Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/26428.
Connect with REL Southeast