Skip to main content

Breadcrumb

Home arrow_forward_ios Information on IES-Funded Research arrow_forward_ios Efficacy of the START-Play Program ...
Home arrow_forward_ios ... arrow_forward_ios Efficacy of the START-Play Program ...
Information on IES-Funded Research
Grant Closed

Efficacy of the START-Play Program for Infants with Neuromotor Disorders

NCSER
Program: Special Education Research Grants
Program topic(s): Early Intervention and Early Learning
Award amount: $3,430,109
Principal investigator: Regina Harbourne
Awardee:
Duquesne University
Year: 2015
Project type:
Efficacy
Award number: R324A150103

Purpose

The purpose of this project was to evaluate the efficacy of Sitting Together And Reaching To Play (START-Play), an intervention designed to target sitting, reaching, and motor-based problem solving to improve development and readiness to learn in infants with motor delays or movement dysfunction. There is limited research examining the efficacy of early physical intervention on infants with neuromotor dysfunction. In addition, most early motor interventions have not been directly linked to learning, despite the research demonstrating an association between motor activity and cognitive skills. START-Play specifically targets motor and cognitive skills that lead to greater physical exploration, which has been associated with improved problem solving and global development. A randomized controlled trial of START-Play was conducted across five states to investigate the impact of the intervention on changes over time in sitting and reaching, subsequent changes in global cognitive development, and the mediating influences of motor skill changes and problem solving.

Project Activities

The research team conducted a randomized controlled trial to evaluate the impact of START-Play on motor development, motor problem solving, and global development including cognitive problem solving of infants with neuromotor delay and dysfunction. Infants experienced either the START-Play intervention + services as usual or only services as usual for 3 months, with initial follow-up assessments at three time points up until 9 months post intervention. The research team examined group differences in outcomes, potential moderators, and whether the short-term impacts of the intervention on motor-based development mediate longer-term impacts on global cognitive development.

Structured Abstract

Setting

The research took place in the homes of infants and their families in Pennsylvania, Delaware, Washington, Nebraska, and Virginia.

Sample

There were 134 infants (age 7 to 16 months) with neuromotor disorders, as well as their families and interventionists, randomized into treatment and control groups at the start of this study. Infants had gross motor delays but were able to sit propped up for at least 3 seconds when they were recruited for participation. At the end of the study only 112 infants fit all inclusion criteria and were used in all analyses.
Intervention
Sitting Together And Reaching To Play (START-Play) is an intervention for infants with motor dysfunction or delay in which physical therapists visit the child's home to target work on sitting, reaching, and problem solving. The therapist visits the home twice weekly for 3 months. During these visits, therapists and families work together to provide intensive, individualized, daily activities to advance reaching and sitting through small increments of challenge and support for these skills, which then become the building blocks for motor-based problem solving. More specifically, the intervention focuses on self-initiated, goal-directed movements to build orientation and attention to objects, while learning basic relationships of cause and effect. Infants and families in the intervention group received this intervention in addition to their usual early intervention services.

Research design and methods

This study used a randomized controlled trial in which infants and their families were randomly assigned to the intervention group (START-Play in addition to usual services) or control group (usual early intervention services), stratified by severity of neuromotor disorder. There were 24 intervention sessions during the 12-week intervention period, with assessments occurring at baseline, 1.5, 3, 6 and 12 months post-baseline follow-up visits. The study tested the efficacy of the intervention on sitting and reaching (proximal outcomes) and motor-based problem-solving skills (longer-term proximal outcome), which were hypothesized to serve as mediators to the more distal outcomes of global cognitive development and readiness to learn. The investigators also explored fidelity of implementation to identify conditions that support fidelity and outcomes, as well as identifying other moderating factors related to the child (severity of disorder, health, cognitive skill at entry), family (socioeconomic status, home environment), or services (fidelity of implementation, other services provided to child) to explore change over time. With additional funding, the research team examined longer-term impacts of START-Play by collecting follow-up data at 24 and 36 months post baseline.

Control condition

Infants and their families in the control condition continued to receive their regular IDEA Part C early intervention services.

Key measures

Primary outcome measures in the study included the Gross Motor Function Measure and an observational measure of toy contacts for sitting and reaching, as well as an adapted version of the Individual and Growth Development Indicators (Early Problem Solving Indicator) and Bayley Scales of Infant and Toddler Development —Third Edition for problem solving and global development. Secondary measures included additional measures of postural control and reaching, child and family characteristics, and fidelity of implementation (video coding of intervention). At the longer-term follow up, additional outcomes were measured with the Dimensions of Mastery Questionnaire (caregiver report of characteristics associated with future academic success, such as persistence), Minnesota Executive Function Scale, Bayley III or DAYC-2 (depending on age or in person availability),and Gross Motor Function Measure.

Data analytic strategy

The investigators used piecewise linear mixed modeling (LMM) to determine the efficacy of the intervention on child outcomes. Parallel piecewise growth modeling within a structural equation modeling framework was used to examine whether short-term improvements in sitting, reaching, fine motor skills, and motor-based problem-solving mediate long-term improvements in global cognitive development. LMM was also used to examine moderating variables, as well as secondary motor outcomes. Longer-term outcomes were examined through analysis of covariance.

Key outcomes

The main findings of this project, as reported by the principal investigator, are as follows:

People and institutions involved

IES program contact(s)

Amy Sussman

Education Research Analyst
NCSER

Products and publications

ERIC Citations: Find available citations in ERIC for this award here.

Publicly Available Data: The final dataset and corresponding documentation will be deposited in the University of Nebraska-Lincoln Data Repository (https://dataregistry.unl.edu). Researchers interested in accessing the data will be required to complete a Data Use Agreement Form.

WWC Review: https://ies.ed.gov/ncee/wwc/Study/90301

Project Website: http://start-play.unl.edu/

Project Video: (created through IES) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZrIo0zXgkdQ

Additional online resources and information:
Study video for recruitment: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mP7-Eo-EBe4&t=27s
Object permanence video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dAaMAoomjWg&t=39s
Fidelity video:  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UEat5MVwZFM

Select Publications

Journal articles

An, M., Nord, J., Koziol, N. A., Dusing, S. C., Kane, A. E., Lobo, M. A., … & Harbourne, R. T. (2021). Developing a fidelity measure of early intervention programs for children with neuromotor disorders. Developmental Medicine & Child Neurology, 63(1), 97-103.

Cunha, A. B., Babik, I., Koziol, N. A., Hsu, L. Y., Nord, J., Harbourne, R. T., ... & Lobo, M. A. (2021). A novel means-end problem-solving assessment tool for early intervention: Evaluation of validity, reliability, and sensitivity. Pediatric Physical Therapy, 33(1), 2-9.

Cunha, A. B., Babik, I., Harbourne, R., Cochran, N. J., Stankus, J., Szucs, K., & Lobo, M. A. (2020). Assessing the validity and reliability of a new video goniometer app for measuring joint angles in adults and children. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 101(2), 275-282.

Harbourne, R. T., Dusing, S. C., Lobo, M. A., McCoy, S. W., Koziol, N. A., Hsu, L. Y., ... & Sheridan, S. M. (2021). START-Play physical therapy intervention impacts motor and cognitive outcomes in infants with neuromotor disorders: A multisite randomized clinical trial. Physical Therapy, 101(2), 1-11.

Harbourne, R. T., Dusing, S. C., Lobo, M. A., Westcott-McCoy, S., Bovaird, J., Sheridan, S., ... & Babik, I. (2018). Sitting Together and Reaching to Play (START-play): protocol for a multisite randomized controlled efficacy trial on intervention for infants with neuromotor disorders. Physical therapy, 98(6), 494-502.

Jensen-Willett, S., Cunha, A., Lobo, M. A., Harbourne, R., Dusing, S. C., McCoy, S. W., ... & Bovaird, J. A. (2022). The effect of early-life seizures on cognitive and motor development: A case series. Pediatric Physical Therapy, 34(3), 425-431

Koziol, N. A., Butera, C. D., Kretch, K. S., Harbourne, R. T., Lobo, M. A., McCoy, S. W., ... & Dusing, S. C. (2022). Effect of the START-Play physical therapy intervention on cognitive skills depends on caregiver-provided learning ppportunities. Physical & Occupational Therapy In Pediatrics, 1-16.

Molinini, R. M., Koziol, N. A., Marcinowski, E. C.; Hsu, L., Tripathi, T., Harbourne, R. T., McCoy, S. W., Lobo, M. A., Bovaird, J. A., Dusing, S. C. (2021). Early motor skills predict the developmental trajectory of problem solving in young children with motor delays. Developmental Psychobiology, 63, 1-12.

Molinini, R. M., Koziol, N. A., Tripathi, T., Harbourne, R. T., McCoy, S. W., Lobo, M. A., ... & Dusing, S. C. (2020). Measuring early problem-solving in young children with motor delays: A validation study. Physical & Occupational Therapy In Pediatrics, 33, 1-19.

Stuyvenberg, Corri L.; Brown, Shaaron E.; Inamdar, Ketaki; Evans, Megan; Hsu, Lin-ya; Rolin, Olivier; Harbourne, Regina T.; Westcott McCoy, Sarah; Lobo, Michele A.; Koziol, Natalie A.; Dusing, Stacey C. , (2021) Targeted physical therapy combined with spasticity management changes motor development trajectory for a 2-year-old with cerebral palsy. Journal of Personalized Medicine, 11(3), Article 163.

Project website:

https://start-play.unl.edu/

Supplemental information

Long-Term Follow-Up Award: 3 Years (FY 2020–FY 2022), $929,509

To examine longer-term impacts of START-Play, the research team received $929,509 in additional funding to collect follow-up data 24 and 36 months after the baseline assessment.

Pre-registration Site: This study was registered at ClinicalTrials.gov (Identifier: NCT02593825)

  • For the full sample (both mild and significant motor delay together), there were significant short-term effects (0-3 months) in favor of the START-Play group for sitting skills and fine motor skills.
  • For infants with significant motor delay, the positive effects of START-Play were observed at 3 months for Bayley cognition, Bayley fine motor, and problem-solving skills as measured by the Assessment of Problem Solving in Play.
  • For infants with mild delays there were significantly positive effects for the START-Play group in receptive communication, but significant negative effects on problem solving.
  • For what was initially to be the longer-term outcomes (up to 12 months), across all children, there was a significant positive effect of START-Play on Bayley fine motor scores.
  • For infants with significant motor delay, significantly positive longer-term effects (up to 12 months) for the START-Play group were found for fine motor and reaching frequency outcomes, as measured by the Bayley.
  • For infants with mild motor delay, no significant difference was found between the START-Play and usual care groups in motor or cognitive outcomes.
  • Motor-based problem-solving mediated the longer-term impact of START-Play on cognition for infants with significant motor delay. START-Play initiated positive short-term changes (baseline to 3 months post baseline) in problem-solving, which accelerated longer-term changes (3 to 12 month post baseline) in cognition. Sitting, reaching, and fine motor skills did not mediate the intervention effect.
  • Baseline caregiver-provided learning opportunities (parent-child interaction) moderated the 3- and 12-month effects of START-Play on cognition. Cognitive gains due to START-Play were more pronounced for children whose caregivers provided more learning opportunities.
  • Analysis of the longer-term outcomes (24 to 36 months), using the supplemental funding, did not support the maintance of positive outcomes for any of the primary outcomes including gross motor skills, fine motor skills, cognitive skills, language skills, or problem solving, nor were there group differences in parent-child interactions. However, note that much of this period of time took place in the early stages of the pandemic shutdown.
  • An analysis on the subset of children who participated up to the final 36-month follow-up assessment suggested that early bimanual object manipulation and corresponding visuomanual coordination may serve as important precursors for developing exuctive functioning skills in children with motor delays. These early sensorimotor behaviors may facilitate the development of attention to a task, goal-directedness, and problem solving, thus providing the foundation for more complex executive function skills. Identification of sensorimotor precursors to emerging EF skills may support the design of early interventions to improve EF outcomes in at-risk populations.

Questions about this project?

To answer additional questions about this project or provide feedback, please contact the program officer.

 

Tags

Early childhood education

Share

Icon to link to Facebook social media siteIcon to link to X social media siteIcon to link to LinkedIn social media siteIcon to copy link value

Questions about this project?

To answer additional questions about this project or provide feedback, please contact the program officer.

 

You may also like

Zoomed in IES logo
Blog

Celebrating the ECLS-K:2024: Parents Contributing ...

September 25, 2024 by IES Staff
Read More
Zoomed in IES logo
Grant

Development of a Technology-Supported Adaptive Int...

Award number: R324A240080
Read More
Zoomed in IES logo
Grant

Statistical Innovations for Balancing Weight Metho...

Award number: R305D240036
Read More
icon-dot-govicon-https icon-quote